If you typed the words “why I have trust issues” into a search bar, you are probably tired of being told to just let people in. You have tried. Somewhere inside you there is a voice that watches every new person, every compliment, every promise, and quietly asks what they really want. You may hate that voice. You may also suspect it has saved you more than once.
I want to talk to you the way I would talk to a young officer sitting across the table from me after a bad stretch. I spent a career in law enforcement, fire service, private security, and federal government, and I have watched trust get broken in more ways than I could list. I have also broken it and had it broken in me. So I am going to be plain with you. Trust issues do not come from nowhere. They come from somewhere specific, and once you know where, you can decide what to do with them.
Trust Issues Are a Record, Not a Defect
The first thing I want you to hear is that your suspicion was learned. Nobody is born expecting to be lied to. A child hands over trust with both hands until someone teaches him that doing so costs something. Every time a promise was broken, a secret was used against you, or a person you leaned on stepped aside at the moment you needed them, your mind wrote it down. What you call trust issues is the sum of those entries. It is a ledger, and the ledger is accurate.
In security work we operate on a doctrine I have carried my whole career. Trust should be tested, not assumed. We do not hand a stranger the keys because he seems nice. We verify, we watch how he handles small responsibilities, and we let access grow with evidence. When I explain this to people who struggle with trust, something relaxes in their shoulders. They realize that what they have been doing by instinct is close to what professionals do on purpose. The difference is that the professional has a process, and the wounded person has only a wall.
The Four Places Trust Usually Breaks
In my experience, trust issues trace back to one of four sources, and most people carry more than one. The first is the home you grew up in. If a parent was unpredictable, if love came and went with their mood, or if the adults in your life said one thing and did another, you learned early that people cannot be counted on. That lesson goes deep because it was written before you had words for it.
The second is betrayal by someone close. A spouse who lied, a friend who repeated what you told them in confidence, a business partner who took what was yours. This kind of wound is sharp because you chose that person. You vetted them, in your own way, and they passed. When they turn, you stop trusting them and you also stop trusting your own judgment. That second loss is the one people underestimate.
The third is betrayal by a leader or an institution. I have watched good people get chewed up by a boss who smiled at them in the hallway and worked against them behind a closed door. I have watched it happen in police departments, in corporations, and yes, in churches. When the person or organization that was supposed to protect you becomes the threat, you learn to distrust anyone with authority over you. The pattern is as old as David serving in the court of Saul, a king who honored him in public and threw a spear at him in private.
The fourth is your own history of being the one who broke trust. This is the source people least want to admit. If you have lied, cheated, or abandoned someone, you know exactly how easy it is to do. You know how convincing a person can be while they are doing it. That knowledge makes you watch others more closely, because you recognize the moves.
What Your Suspicion Is Trying to Do for You
Your trust issues have a job, and the job is to keep you from being hurt the same way twice. That is a good job. The problem is that the guard on duty does not know the difference between a real threat and a person who simply reminds you of one. So it stops everybody at the gate. It keeps out the con man and the friend. It flags the boss who is scheming and the boss who just had a bad morning. Over time you get safer and lonelier in equal measure.
I want you to stop treating that guard as an enemy. Thank it. It got you here. Then give it better instructions, because a guard who only knows how to say no is as useless as a guard who only knows how to say yes. The goal is discernment, and discernment is a skill you can build.
How to Turn a Wall Into a Gate
Start by writing down the specific events that taught you not to trust. Do it on paper, in your own hand. Name the person, name what they did, and name what it cost you. Most people who struggle with trust have never done this. They carry the wounds as a fog rather than a list, and fog cannot be examined. When you see the entries laid out, you will usually notice that they share a shape. Maybe every betrayal came from someone who flattered you first. Maybe every one came from someone you were financially dependent on. That shape is the actual threat you need to guard against, and it is much narrower than everyone.
Next, build a testing process instead of a verdict. When someone new enters your life, decide in advance what small trust you will extend first and what you will watch for. Tell them something minor and see if it comes back to you from another mouth. Ask them to do something small and see if they follow through. Let access grow one step at a time as the evidence comes in. This is how I have vetted people my whole career, and it works in friendship and marriage just as well as it works in a security operation. You are no longer guessing. You are observing.
Then separate the old wound from the new person. When you feel that familiar tightening in your chest, ask yourself one question: what has this person actually done? If the answer is nothing yet, the alarm is coming from the past, and you can acknowledge it without obeying it. Joseph had every reason to distrust his brothers when they showed up in Egypt, and he did test them, carefully and over time, before he revealed himself. He did not pretend the past had not happened. He also did not let it make the decision for him.
The Part Nobody Tells You
You will get burned again. I am not going to tell you otherwise, because I have lived long enough to know it. Judas sat at the table with the best judge of character who ever walked this earth, and he still betrayed him. Perfect discernment is not available to any of us. What is available is resilience, the knowledge that you survived it before and you have a process for handling it now. The person with a process recovers in months. The person with only a wall stays behind it for years.
So here is where I will leave you. Your trust issues are real, they came from real events, and they have been doing a real job. Honor that. Then take the guard off the wall and put him at the gate, where he can let the right people in slowly and keep the wrong ones out for good reasons. That is the difference between a person who is closed and a person who is careful, and careful is a fine thing to be.
Go Deeper
If your trust was broken by someone in authority, a boss or a leader who seemed to be on your side right up until they were not, I wrote a book about that exact pattern. It walks through how David survived a king who wanted to see him fall, and how you can survive yours without becoming like him: The Spirit of Saul.
Commissioner William Epps is an author and security leadership consultant with a background in law enforcement, fire service, private security, and federal government. His books are published through E.P.P.S. Method Publishing Co.
Leave a Reply